Housekeeping Time
Caroline Morris-Brown is famous for her so-called "housekeeping" posts whereby, in her usual patronising manner, she likes to educate us with "facts", usually unsourced, some of which are revealed for the very first time from her bag of secret documents.
But how reliable are her "housekeeping" posts?
When it comes to the meeting at Baker Street attended by Paul Feldman, Keith Skinner, Martin Howells and Michael Barrett on 20th July 1995 the answer is: not very.
Take this "housekeeping" post from 4 September 2020 (Post #6100 in the "Incontrovertible" thread on Casebook) which was supposed to "clear up a few false assumptions and suspicions".

As we can see, she confidently told us:
"Keith first heard about the red diary on 20th July 1995, at Baker Street, during a recorded conversation with Mike, Feldman and Martin Howells. Mike mentions it at one point and nobody seems to know what he's talking about. He accuses Feldman of knowing about it and wants him to admit it."
But six years later on 1 September 2026, in another "Housekeeping" post, she posted this previously unknown transcript of an exchange which occurred on 20th July 1995:

So we can see that Feldman says of the red diary, "I told Keith about it before today", i.e. before 20th July 1995, and Keith confirmed that this was true.
So it was false to say that Keith "first heard" about the red diary on 20th July 1995, wasn't it?
What a fantastic piece of housekeeping that was in September 2020.
It was also completelly false for her to have said in September 2020 that when Mike mentioned the red diary "nobody seems to know what he's talking about". That must have come out of her very imagination. The very opposite is, in fact, true because immediately after Feldman (not Mike) first mentioned the red diary, and said he had previously told Keith Skinner about it, Keith Skinner said, "Yeah, that's true. Confirmed.", thus indicating that he already knew of its existence.
It's odd because the remaining information in the highlighted paragraph of her 2000 post must have been derived from that same transcript. Hence, as we can see, she wrote:
"Feldman says Melvin Harris was told that Mike had a receipt proving Anne bought a Victorian diary. Feldman asks Mike why he told Melvin that the diary was bought in 1992 for £25. Feldman says it's a little diary dated 1891. He asks Mike why he implied to Melvin that the receipt for it proved Anne wrote the diary."
This seems to be a direct summary of the exchange from the transcript extract that she posted on 1st September 2026. How could she, in September 2020, have missed it being expressly stated that Keith already knew about the red diary before 20th July 1995? How could she have thought that Mike was the person who mentioned it? And how could she have thought nobody knew what he meant?
Well I say "direct summary" but it's not entirely accurate is it?
Firstly, Feldman did not say on 20th July1995 that Melvin Harris was told that Mike had a receipt proving Anne bought a Victorian diary. What Feldman said was that Harris was informed that the receipt proved "that they bought the diary". Even worse, Feldman then seemed to confuse himself because he changed the word "informed" to "implied" and changed "they" to "Anne", asking Mike why he implied to Harris that the receipt proved that Anne wrote the diary (as opposed to bought it), thus appearing to contradict what he'd said only a few moments earlier.
Secondly, Feldman did not ask Mike why he told Melvin that the diary was bought "in 1992" for £25. We can see that the year of purchase was not mentioned by Feldman. Nor did Feldman ask Mike why he told Melvin that the diary was bought for £25. That seems to be another thing to have come purely from the imagination of Morris-Brown.
Yet, because a full transcript of the meeting had never previously been made available (and still hasn't), we'd all had to rely on Morris-Brown entirely for the accuracy of that summary, which it turns out was sorely lacking.
Another thing of interest from this transcript is that Feldman described the red diary as "a little red velvet Victorian pocketbook diary dated 1891, printed with lines on it." He didn't refer to it as an appointments diary nor did he even say that it had dates on every page. Just printed "with lines" on it. Yet according to the Gruesome Twosome - Morris-Brown and Mitchell - nobody could ever have possibly described that diary as anything other than an appointments diary with printed dates on every page. Strange how reality easily destroys these fabricated online arguments, isn't it?
We can see that Morris-Brown ends her post by referring to Mike's "1891 secret". This would appear to be a fantasy of hers. Mike probably couldn't remember the exact year of the diary at the time he was speaking to Alan Gray in late 1994 or early 1995. It's now confirmed that Anne had possession of the diary (although why she did is another issue) so Mike may not have had the chance to refresh his memory. Plus there were no "obvious attempts at deflection" by Mike relating to the year of the diary. Feldman mentioned the year 1891 immediately after informing Mike for the first time that Anne had given him the diary at which point Mike hadn't even had a chance to speak. Morris-Brown was clearly imagining the deflection in terms of the year. The best that can be said is that Mike deflected the question of why Mike implied to Melvin Harris that the receipt proved that Anne wrote the diary, which is a different matter entirely. Whether Mike did actually "imply" this is yet another matter. And how Feldman could possibly have known what Mike had said or implied to Melvin Harris is yet another matter entirely.
As to that, we can see in the next paragraph of her 4 September 2020 post, Morris Brown tells us that
"It would appear that Feldman got his information from Melvin Harris".

This always seemed unlikely because Harris and Feldman were on very bad terms in 1995 and we can see from the transcript that Feldman got his information about the "little diary dated 1891" in large part from Anne Barrett even though the fact of Feldman having spoken to Anne was not mentioned in Missy's 2020 "housekeeping" post.
Furthermore, as we know, it was Mike who told Feldman about the red diary in the first place, informing him in a telephone call in late June 1995, according to Keith's note, that "Ann had bought a Victorian diary in 1991 (!) for which he (Barrett), had the receipt." Given the Mike said he had the receipt and evidently knew the diary had cost £25, I can't help wondering if, in fact, he was talking about having bought a Victorian diary from 1891 which Feldman misheard, or Mike muddled 1891 with 1991. However, as we know, Mike did confuse the events of 1992 with those of 1991 so both scenarios are possible.
Another point of some interest here is that more than a month after the 20th July 1995 meeting, in which it had been stated that the red diary was purchased for £25, Keith Skinner's note of his conversation with Anne on 22nd August 1995 said this:
"All Ann can clearly remember is having to pay £20 for it – is going to search for cheque stubs !"
So Mike's understanding of the facts was rather better than Anne's considering that Feldman noted that Harris had been informed by Mike that there was a receipt for £25, which was the correct purchase amount. One might think it even means that Mike did possess a receipt at that time, even though it's never been seen by anyone else.
But perhaps the most important issue to emerge from this newly provided transcript of the 20th July 1995 meeting, which I've already touched upon, is that Feldman had spoken to Anne about the red diary prior to that meeting. And that conversation must have been in person for Anne to have handed the diary to Feldman. Why is that important? Well the impression we've been given is that Keith telephoned Anne out of the blue on 22nd August 1995 to ask her about the red diary and she gave her immediate, honest reaction.
My own response to this was that Anne had, in fact, known about the importance of the red diary since January 1995 when she read Mike's affidavit which Mike had posted through her door. But there is now an added dimension whereby at some point before 20th July 1995 she had discussed the red diary in person with a sympathetic Paul Feldman. All we know from Feldman's account at the July 1995 meeting is that he said to Anne, "Mike says you've got the receipt for the diary", to which she replied, "Yeah, here's the diary". So was she confirming that she had the receipt or wasn't she? Either way, Anne had plenty of time to think about the story she would tell if asked by Keith Skinner about it. And it wouldn't be surprising if the conversation between Feldman and Anne was much longer and more detailed than a single brief exchange. Feldman is not known for his brevity or his trustworthiness and one can't help wondering if he asked her at length why Mike had wanted that 1891 diary in the first place, and went over various possibilities with her, so that she was ready with a story when Keith Skinner later asked her the same question.
It's also interesting that Anne only decided to search for her cheque stubs after speaking to Keith Skinner on 22nd August 1995 even though Feldman had asked her about the diary more than a month before this.
I should say that Keith Skinner made a note of a call with Paul Feldman on 5th July 1995 in which he wrote:
"PF [Paul Feldman] phoned and asked me to make a note that last week, before he went to Liverpool, Mike Barrett had phoned saying Ann had bought a Victorian diary in 1991 (!) for which he (Barrett), had the receipt. PF asked Anne about it - and Anne said, yes, she had bought a Victorian pocket diary - and still has it."
Unfortunately, when Tom Mitchell posted the transcript of this note in June 2023 (apparently revealing it for the first time) there was a missing quotation mark which meant that it wasn't entirely clear if the second sentence was written by Keith in 1995 or in 2023. See what I mean:

An unfortunate failure of punctuation which mixed Keith's 1995 note with his obsservations from 2023 without making clear the distinction between the two.
But what we can see from Keith's 5th July 1995 note (once it is appreciated that it comprises two sentences, not one) is that Anne apparently admitted to Feldman in late June or early July 1995 that "she" had bought a Victorian pocket diary. This seemingly corroborates what Mike said in his January 1995 affidavit as below:
"In fact Anne purchased a Diary, a red leather backed Diary for £25.00p, she made the purchase through a firm in the 1986 Writters Year Book, I cannot remember their name, she paid for the Diary by cheque in the amount of £25 which was drawn on her Lloyds Bank Account, Water Street Branch, Liverpool."
It is noteworthy that Mike also said in his affidavit:
"My wife is now in possession of this Diary in fact she asked for it specifically recently when I saw her at her home address..."
Given that it was true that Anne was in possession of the red diary for some unknown reason in late June or early July 1995, could it also be true that she had asked Mike for it when he saw her at some point in either late 1994 or early January 1995?
It's odd isn't it how diary defenders don't seem to wonder why Anne was in possession of the red diary in the summer of 1995. Sure, she'd paid for it but the story she told was that Mike wanted the red diary to see what a Victorian diary looked like. That diary was, apparently, sent by Martin Earl to Mike Barrett, not to Anne. Mike, therefore, must have been in possession of it in March 1992. So how and why did Anne end up with it in 1995? What did she want with it? It doesn't appear to have been as a financial investment because, after having given it to Feldman, she gave it away to Keith Skinner. At least, if either of them had to pay to get it, this hasn't been revealed.
THE HOUSEKEEPER'S GENEROSITY
You might be wondering why Caroline Morris-Brown actually posted the transcript extract from the meeting of 20th July 1995 in her JTR forums "housekeeping" post of 1st September 2026. Was it a sudden burst of generosity from her? Was she revealing some new information to the forum members out of the goodness of her heart?
Of course not!
The only reason for her producing this transcript extract was to contradict Michael Banks who had suggested, on the basis of the publicly available evidence at the time, that Feldman had learnt about the 1891 date of the red diary from Mike, whereas Morris-Brown was revealing for the very first time, from the hitherto suppressed and secret transcript extract, that Anne had actually given the diary to Feldman so that he would have known the date from having seen it.
As usual, therefore, a new piece of information is only revealed when it suits the interest of a diary defender to score a cheap point in an online argument. Also, as usual, it rebounded on the diary defender for all the reasons set out above.
THE FINAL TWIST
But there is one more twist to this story. Because when Caroline Morris made her "housekeeping" post on 4 September 2020 to tell us that "Keith first heard about the red diary on 20th July 1995", it was shortly after an earlier claim that Keith Skinner had first heard about the diary on 5th July 1995 which she, no doubt, regarded as one of the "false assumptions" she needed to correct but which turns out to have been true.
Who had made that claim?
None other than Mr Thomas Mitchell, a man not known for getting his facts right. For, on 31st July 2020, just over a month before Missy's famous "housekeeping" post, he had stepped into the controversy surrounding the dreadful error in the Linder, Skinner & Morris book, Inside Story, in which the reader is (wrongly) told that Skinner had been aware of the contents of Michael Barrett's 5th January 1995 affidavit since at least 18th January 1995. In posting an admission by Keith on 31st July 2020 that he "takes full responsibility for the error", thus gallantly protecting the real culprit, Caroline Morris, who had already confessed that, "I think the problem was my fault", we were told by Mitchell:
"Keith points out that he only became aware of the maroon diary on July 5 1995...this reassures him that he definitely wasn't aware of the latter when he interviewed Barrett on Jan 18, 1995".

That was news to me at the time. Skinner's note of his 5th July 1995 conversation with Feldman had not then been made public. I immediately started an online campaign to press for an explanation as to how Keith Skinner had become aware of the maroon diary on 5th July 1995 so that he was able to ask Anne about it in August 1995.
This was picked up by Roger Palmer who asked Morris directly on 4th August 2020:
"Why was Keith quizzing Anne about the red diary if he didn’t know about Barrett’s 5 January 1995 affidavit? When, how, and from whom did he learn of its existence? I’m curious."
Naturally, she didn't answer, quelle surprise, so Roger asked Tom Mitchell on 22nd August 2020 if he was able to assist:
"By the way, Ike, have you had any luck in ascertaining from Keith how he first learned about the red diary? It's a bit of a mystery why he was quizzing Anne Graham about it, when we are informed he wasn't aware of Mike Barrett's sworn affidavit until years later. Who told Keith about the red diary's existence? I am not suggesting anything untoward: I am just confused about what is being claimed. Keith kept such meticulous notes that he must know how he first learned of it, if not from Barrett's affidavit, then from whom?"
It was following on from this, a few days, later that we got Missy's famous misinformational "housekeeping" post in which, despite Keith Skinner, as we've seen, having already posted via Tom Mitchell that he first became aware of the red diary on 5th July 1995, she told us confidently that he only first became aware of it at the meeting on 20th July 1995, thus confusing the record which wasn't properly cleared up by Mitchell's June 2023 post due to the incompetent punctuation and has only really been fully resolved (inadvertently) by Missy's recent posting of the new extract of the 20th July 1995 transcript.
And the problem this reveals is that at the very heart of the story of the red diary is none other than the untrustworthy chancer Paul Feldman who had spoken to Anne about it alone and in person long before Keith Skinner did over the telephone and had thus had every opportunity to help her create a plausible sounding false narrative about why she had purchased it back in 1992 which she could then relay to Keith. Just another very sorry story in this protracted diary saga which we've learnt about for the first time in 2026.
LORD ORSAM
12 November 2026









Comments